Translate

Friday, 16 January 2015

Signage in Los Angeles and New York

When we view signs we draw information from them immediately almost subconsciously. These signs have to be clear in their messages and visibly readable to the naked eye. Without signs what would the world do? Signs allow us to predict things before they happen. This is how I see the world sometimes I recognise the signs long before others do. Being hearing impaired you have to be able to recognise the signs quickly in order to make sense of the world and others. Those who are hearing impaired or deaf have to be one step ahead of the pack, because we have to compensate for the hearing loss by using our eyes. Not only does this include signage but it also includes visual cues such as body language. The ability of visually reading what someone is saying or predicting what someone is about to talk about just from their facial expressions and gestures.

Saussre's theory of the sign was made up of its "bilateral structure" (Winfried 1990, p.59) which included the sign and accompanied by the signifier and signified. The signifier is the name we give to a tree and the signified is the image of the tree. These signs have been instilled in our minds since we were young and have stuck with us into adulthood.


                    http://www.nocleansinging.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/09/signifier-sign-signified.png




Of course without meaning behind the signified there is no valid understanding of the sign as a whole. Sometimes visual cues are all it takes to understand something which is integral for those who have hearing problems. Take for example the seatbelt sign on an airplane, the image clearly highlights what action is to be performed. The signified when lit up instructs people to put their seat belts on which is only undertaken because of our understanding of the signifier. The sign is also a generic image understood by those globally. It could almost be considered a universal symbol because it requires associating the symbol with the image of a seatbelt in front of you.

                                    

People tend to forget that although we may look at things in different perspectives depending on our ethnic background and so. We actually see many things the same especially symbols whether we understand them or not. Therefore looking through my eyes may not be all that different from your own, however seeing through my eyes and having my hearing impairment might just let you into a world other than your own which is made up of primarily visual cues. There are many visual cues that are understood the same all around the world. For example, using thumbs up, nodding and smiling. However, Americans tend to give more direct contact which is shown especially when you are ordering food. Americans do not want to know what you are thinking of having, they just want you to tell them exactly what you want. This tends to be more apparent in the more populated cities such as Los Angeles and New York because they do not have time for you to be annoying customers behind you and wasting their time. Transportation in Los Angeles is difficult due to the amount of people present there and far distances. Public transportation around the area is limited although it is getting better. They are working on ways for LA to become easier to manoeuvre around. However in New York elevators on each platform provide an ease of access to platforms for those disabled and in wheelchairs. Also provided are emergency exits, which allow enough space for someone in a wheelchair to exit with ease. I am unsure how they would get to the streets due to the large amount of people and predominately steep steps.


Everywhere in the United States there is bins for both recycled trash products. However this organised rubbish in a café store in Soho striked me as the bin has been organised even further than just recyclables and trash. This is something uncommon to bins in Melbourne. Due to America being overpopulated with millions of people especially in New York it is integral to have such organised trash. The colour coded signage and images of the sort of rubbish to place in each bin is helpful because it reduces confusion for where to place rubbish and makes it easier for those collecting garbage. The signage here is very clear and understandable to those who understand the English language. The limitation about most signage in America is those who do not know English would place their rubbish into the wrong bins which could be a problem at a later stage.

What I have noticed about America wide is the use of plain and simple typography, which is not too confronting except for those huge signs which draw your attention. These massive signs make it almost impossible to look at anything else.









             









The signage in the subway are to the point and easy to read. The helvetica typography is simple yet effective and the text is big enough for the visually impaired to see. The colours of different train lines are effective and easier to understand compared to Melbourne's train lines. The incorporation of downtown and uptown also makes it much easier to know which way you are going and allows you to realise if it says uptown and you are meant to go downtown then you must be at the wrong platform. Although, it might be assumed that New York City's train system has always been organised this well, however this is not so. In the 1960s signage in the New York City subway was terrible because there was an abundance of signs and no one knew where to go. Nevertheless in 1970, two unimark designers Massimo Vignelli and Bob Noorda established "decision by decision created an analysis of how people use the subway" (Smyth & Reed 2014). Michael Bient also states that the stories had always been about the numbers in the subway. He describes the signs as "simple almost kindergarten level clarity" (Smyth & Reed 2014). However the book is very sophisticated in regards to its analysis of the subway system. The signage represents even modern design and the idea that less is more.

Here is an example of what is provided in the New York City Transit Authority Graphics Standards Manual:




                                                               http://thestandardsmanual.com
This customer assistance sign contains no written information accompanying the sign and explaining what the sign is about as it is intended to be understood by the generic public.



Although this sign may not have instructed written communication it is striking to a deaf community, because there is no need to read anything as the sign relies solely upon the public understanding the visual communication and even body language. This is something important to deaf people because we rely on visual communication to understand what someone is trying to say especially if we cannot fully hear what they are trying to say. Visual cues can aid deaf people to understand what people are saying even if we cannot hear them saying it.  This is prominent in sign language as interpreters tend to over exaggerate visual expressions to assist the deaf in understanding exactly what they are trying to say.

Neoth Winfried (1990) explains in the Handbook of Semiotics that Bulwer (1644) believed gestures were superior of the spoken language and even suggested gestural communication be adopted by humans as a universal language (Winfried 1990, p.282). Also shown in sign language is the overexaggeration of lip movements which are important for understanding what someone is trying to say because, lip reading assists in ensuring the deaf or hearing impaired individual understands every word someone speaks.
                                   

This video highlights the difference in pedestrian crossings when compared to Melbourne as we do not get a count down for crossing the road. In Melbourne we are given a flashing red man saying quickly cross the road before you get run over. Whereas in America this would be flashing orange hand indicating stop which makes sense as that is a universal sign.

Signs can also include advertising as they provide an audience with meaning of brands. It is interesting to compare the advertising of America and Australia because American advertising tends to be larger and more colourful and visually appearing as shown in the image below. The typography is bold and more directly in your face which represents the way Americans communicate verbally. It also seems like the Australian packaging of the same brand appears healthier especially with the accompanying tooth under the typography.


Times Square is like a haven for deaf people because they do not need to hear anything to understand what the advertisement is trying to tell them. The only thing is there has to be a prior understanding of such popular advertisements to understand what it is they are trying to portray to you. Winfried explains how "semiotic concepts connotation and ideology" were believed to be the "key to advertising analysis" (Winfried 1990, p.477).
Perhaps this is so, because to target an audience and get people to buy your product you have to appeal to them in an ideological way where they may see themselves happier if they have the item. Winfried also goes on to say how ideologists have criticising the advertising industry for "manipulating the public with such secretive strategies" (Winfried 1990, p.477). One would have to ask are these really secretive strategies or are they just signs that we have come to accept? We like to see visually appealing signs especially if we can relate to them.
For instance in the H&M advertisement below to those who had never heard of the company would not understand they are selling clothes rather than what could be assumed as dancing. The advertisement is visually appealing makes you feel as if you will be rich and dancing around if you are wearing their clothes.


However, what can assist the true understanding of the company is viewing what is inside the store. These strikingly huge advertisements lit up at night are unavoidable and appealing to the eye. Whether you are deaf or not the first thing humans see is lights and this is why most people who go to Times Square are immediately drawn to the lights. However, those who live or pass by Times Square frequently would be less drawn to these advertisements and it would eventually become like a backdrop and allows them to look at the reality of the streets of New York which is the many people throwing CDs, forms, and items in your face. These advertisements along with others used semiotics which is the theoretical tool used for the "analysis of signs and communication processes in advertising" (Winfried 1990, p.476).





Los Angeles is surprisingly different and less extravagant than in New York. Some may have thought more majestic and huge types of advertisement would be more apparent in Los Angeles because Hollywood is right there, however it seems to be the total opposite. Los Angeles tends to be more plain and simple when compared to New York advertising.

Los Angeles signs in terms of advertising tend to be more naturalistic and less extravagantly expressive compared to New York.One could say New York is in fact the fantasy world and Los Angeles is more realistic.



Although Los Angeles advertisements are still huge they are more scattered and shown along freeways and roads because this is primarily the easiest way to get around Los Angeles whereas in New York there are lots of advertisements in the subway and Times Square.
 

This sign would be very important and understandable to a deaf audience because they would understand which way to go. Also those with origins from a non-speaking English background would understand this sign because of the pictorial cue of a wave representing a tsunami or big wave. Arrows are a universal symbol all they would have to do in such an event is follow the arrows located around the area. The capital letters are important because it can be seen from far away and is clear enough for people to see when a tsunami occurs. This is something that would not be seen in Melbourne, as we do not have a major issue with tsunamis or earthquakes.
A world without signs sounds like a world full of chaos.

References
Nèoth, W 1990, Handbook Of Semiotics, Bloomington: Indiana University Press.New York City Transit Authority Graphics Standards Manual 1970, Unimark International, New York, retrieved 15 January 2015, <

Reed, J & Smyth, H 2014, Full-size reissue of the NYCTA Graphics Standards Manual, retrieved 15 January 2015, <https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/thestandardsmanual/full-size-reissue-of-the-nycta-graphics-standards/posts>.
















No comments:

Post a Comment